Refugee Convention 5 grounds, RPD 8-stage hearing process, sur place claims, RAD appeal, PRRA, H&C applications under IRPA s.25, 8 inadmissibility grounds, and Safe Third Country Agreement implications for Ontario immigration lawyers.
Refugee and immigration law is among the most consequential areas of Ontario legal practice. Errors in refugee proceedings can result in refusal and return to a country where a client faces persecution, torture, or death. Ontario immigration lawyers must master the refugee determination process, the appeals available, and the alternative relief mechanisms when claims fail.
Canada's refugee system is governed by the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) and the Refugee Protection Division Rules. The Refugee Protection Division (RPD) and Refugee Appeal Division (RAD) are independent administrative tribunals that operate under the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (IRB).
This guide covers the five Convention grounds for refugee protection, the RPD hearing process, sur place claims, the RAD appeal and Federal Court judicial review, the PRRA, H&C applications, and the inadmissibility grounds Ontario immigration lawyers encounter most frequently.
To qualify as a Convention refugee, a claimant must establish a well-founded fear of persecution based on one of five protected grounds. The fear must be both subjectively genuine and objectively reasonable given country conditions. State protection must be unavailable or inadequate.
| Convention Ground | Definition | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Race | Persecution based on the claimant's racial origin or ethnicity | Ethnic minority persecuted by state or non-state actors; racial profiling by police; ethnically motivated violence |
| Religion | Persecution based on religious beliefs, practices, or identity | Converts persecuted by family or state; religious minorities facing state oppression; apostasy charges |
| Nationality | Persecution based on national origin, citizenship, or statelessness | Stateless persons denied citizenship; persecution of minority nationalities; cross-border ethnic conflict |
| Membership in a particular social group | Persecution based on membership in a group sharing an immutable characteristic or fundamental identity | LGBTQ+ persons; women fleeing gender-based violence; domestic violence victims; gang victimization (case-by-case) |
| Political opinion | Persecution based on actual or perceived political views | Opposition politicians; journalists; human rights activists; trade union leaders; perceived dissidents |
Person in need of protection (IRPA s.97): In addition to Convention refugees, a person may be recognized as a "person in need of protection" if removal would subject them personally to a risk to their life or to risk of cruel and unusual treatment or punishment. This ground captures claimants who do not fit neatly into the Convention grounds but face serious individualized risk in their home country.
Claim can be made at a land border crossing, airport, or at an inland IRCC office
Third country nationals from the US subject to Safe Third Country Agreement (STCA) at official land crossings
CBSA or IRCC determines whether the claimant is eligible to make a refugee claim in Canada
Ineligible if already recognized as refugee in another country, previously rejected in Canada, or subject to extradition
Eligible claimants are referred to the Refugee Protection Division; assigned a hearing date
Claimant must complete Basis of Claim form within 15 days of referral (inland) or at time of claim (border)
Claimant submits detailed written narrative of persecution feared; this is the foundation of the claim
Critical document; inconsistencies between BOC and testimony are a primary credibility concern
Both parties exchange documents; claimant provides country condition evidence and personal documents
Late disclosure requires RPD leave; failure to disclose can result in inadmissibility of evidence
Hearing before a member of the Refugee Protection Division; claimant testifies; member questions
Claimant can request an interpreter; refugee claimant has right to counsel; Crown counsel (IRCC) may intervene
Member issues decision to accept or reject the claim with written reasons
Accepted claims result in Convention refugee or person in need of protection status; rejected claims trigger appeal rights
Rejected claimants may appeal to the Refugee Appeal Division or seek judicial review of RPD decision
RAD cannot hear new evidence except in limited circumstances; Federal Court reviews only for error of law or fact
Even where a claimant has a legitimate refugee claim, they may be inadmissible to Canada on independent grounds. Inadmissibility can result in exclusion from the Convention refugee definition (Article 1F exclusion clause) or removal despite refugee status in serious criminality cases.
| Ground | Basis | IRPA |
|---|---|---|
| Security | Espionage, subversion of democratic government, terrorism, or being a member of a terrorist organization | s. 34 |
| Human or international rights violations | War crimes, crimes against humanity, being a senior official in a government that engaged in torture | s. 35 |
| Serious criminality | Conviction in Canada of an offence punishable by maximum 10 years or more, for which sentence of 6 months or more was imposed | s. 36(1) |
| Criminality (PR and temporary residents) | Conviction for an indictable offence or two summary offences | s. 36(2) |
| Organized criminality | Member of a criminal organization; engaging or having engaged in criminal organization activity | s. 37 |
| Health grounds | Condition that is a danger to public health or public safety, or that would cause excessive demand on health services | s. 38 |
| Financial reasons | Unable or unwilling to support oneself or dependants | s. 39 |
| Misrepresentation | Misrepresenting or withholding material facts in an immigration application; organized fraud schemes | s. 40 |
Under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) and the 1951 Refugee Convention, a Convention refugee is a person who has a well-founded fear of persecution based on one of five grounds: race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. The fear must be both subjective (the claimant genuinely fears persecution) and objective (there is a reasonable basis for the fear given country conditions). The claimant must also be outside their country of nationality or habitual residence.
If the Refugee Protection Division (RPD) rejects a refugee claim, the claimant generally has 15 days to file an appeal to the Refugee Appeal Division (RAD). The RAD may affirm, set aside, or substitute the RPD's decision. If the RAD also rejects the claim, the claimant may apply for a Pre-Removal Risk Assessment (PRRA) and/or make a Humanitarian and Compassionate (H&C) application. Judicial review to the Federal Court is available from RAD decisions within 15 days.
A sur place claim is a refugee claim based on events that occurred after the claimant left their home country. The risk of persecution arises not from conditions that existed when the claimant left, but from changed country conditions or the claimant's own activities in Canada (such as political activism, converting religion, or publicly opposing the home government). Sur place claims are fully recognized under Canadian law but are subject to careful scrutiny — particularly where the claimant's activities in Canada appear designed to manufacture a refugee claim.
A humanitarian and compassionate (H&C) application under IRPA s.25 allows a person who is otherwise inadmissible or ineligible to remain in Canada to request permanent residence on the basis of humanitarian and compassionate considerations. The decision-maker weighs factors including establishment in Canada, best interests of any children directly affected, family ties to Canada, country conditions, and hardship. H&C applications are decided by IRCC officers and are not a refugee determination — a failed refugee claim does not bar an H&C application.
Atticus helps Ontario immigration lawyers track hearing deadlines, manage trust accounting, and keep files LSO-compliant from refugee claim through appeal.
Start Free Trial